The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Pickerington

Nestled in the heart of Pickerington, Ohio, The Old Bag of Nails Pub offers a warm, inviting atmosphere where American pub fare shines with both comforting classics and flavorful twists. This restaurant and bar captures the essence of a neighborhood favorite, blending hearty, satisfying dishes with the casual ambiance of a local gathering spot.

The culinary experience here centers around expertly crafted American fare with a strong emphasis on fresh seafood, juicy burgers, and shareable bar snacks. Regulars rave about the Fish & Chips, boasting a light yet crispy batter that perfectly complements flaky fish inside. The Jumbo Pretzel and Spinach & Artichoke Dip offer irresistible starters that beckon to be shared alongside a cold pour of Guinness or the popular Columbus Brewing Company IPA. Seafood lovers won’t want to miss the Mussels & Jumbo Shrimp, steamed in white wine, butter, and aromatic spices, served with garlic bread that soaks up every last drop of sauce.

Burgers and sandwiches showcase housemade ingredients and thoughtful combinations. The Traditional Reuben, featuring tender corned beef layered with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut on grilled marble rye, is a standout for those craving deep, savory flavors. For something unique, the Sesame Ginger Chicken Sandwich with feta cheese, pickled onions, and fresh spinach offers a vibrant, tangy contrast. You can indulge in such classics as the Chicken Tenders Basket, Boneless Wings, or opt for a more substantial entrée like the Country Fried Chicken or Shrimp & Fish Platter.

The extensive sides menu allows for customizable meals, with crispy Onion Rings, golden Sweet Potato Fries, and refreshing Coleslaw all popular picks. Customers appreciate the generous portions paired with a well-curated drink selection, including delightful specialty cocktails like the refreshing watermelon drink highlighted by one guest.

The dining atmosphere strikes a balance between relaxed and lively. Guests describe the pub as clean with friendly, attentive staff who enhance the meal with genuine hospitality. While some note the interior lighting leans towards dim, adding a cozy pub vibe, it might challenge menu reading for some—but the prompt service and quality food more than make up for it.

Patrons repeatedly commend the consistency and flavor of the dishes; the boneless wings are famously crispy and a preferred go-to, while the fish dishes impress with their delicate textures and expertly prepared batter. Authentic touches and fresh ingredients elevate every bite, making it clear that this establishment values quality and guest satisfaction.

Whether you’re looking to unwind with a cold beer, share a plate with friends, or enjoy a casual lunch, The Old Bag of Nails Pub in Pickerington invites you to experience authentic American comfort food with a friendly neighborhood charm. Expect robust flavors, warm service, and an ambiance that makes you feel right at home.

Contact Information:
797 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147
Phone: (614) 834-3927